
Question
Can a hospital refuse treatment based on non-payment or lack of insurance in Nigeria?
Case scenario
Mr Bassey is rushed to a private hospital in Port Harcourt after a road traffic accident. At the reception, his relatives are asked for an initial deposit before he can be admitted. They cannot immediately raise the funds, and the hospital delays treatment until payment is made. Unfortunately, the patient’s condition worsens, and his family accuses the hospital of negligence for refusing urgent care.
Legal perspective
Under Nigerian law, hospitals (both public and private) are bound by a duty of care once a patient presents for treatment, especially in emergency situations. The National Health Act 2014 (Section 20) explicitly prohibits health workers and facilities from refusing a person emergency medical treatment for any reason, including non-payment. Violation of this provision can attract fines, imprisonment, and regulatory sanctions.
In non-emergency cases, however, private hospitals may lawfully set conditions for treatment, including advance payment or insurance, as part of their contractual relationship with patients. The key distinction is whether the situation is life-threatening or urgent.
Determining liability
Courts in Nigeria would assess:
Nature of the condition – Was it an emergency requiring immediate intervention?
Hospital’s response – Did staff provide stabilising care before addressing payment issues?
Legal obligations – Did the facility comply with Section 20 of the National Health Act?
Documentation – Are there medical records showing timely or delayed intervention?
If refusal of care in an emergency directly caused harm or death, liability may arise under negligence, breach of statutory duty, or even criminal law.
Defences available to hospitals
Non-emergency scenario – If the patient’s condition was not urgent, hospitals may defend their requirement for upfront payment.
Referral provided – Showing that the patient was promptly referred to another facility for care.
Resource limitations – In some cases, lack of available staff, drugs, or equipment may be cited, though this is rarely a complete defence.
Patient consent/choice – If the patient or family declined available care pending financial discussions.
Practical advice for healthcare facilities
Always provide at least stabilising treatment in emergencies, regardless of payment status.
Train frontline staff on legal obligations under the National Health Act.
Document every patient encounter carefully, especially when financial issues arise.
Develop clear policies on deposits and insurance that do not conflict with emergency care obligations.
Ensure collaboration with NHIS and private insurers to expand coverage options for patients.
Closing insight
“While hospitals are businesses with financial realities, the law makes one thing clear: in emergencies, the sanctity of human life overrides the issue of payment.”





