Home Legal Angle Treatment During Industrial Action

Treatment During Industrial Action

0
56
Dozie Ifeanyi Atueyi

 

Question

Are healthcare professionals liable if they treat a patient during a strike in Nigeria?

Case scenario

During a nationwide health workers’ strike, Dr Yusuf, a government hospital consultant, decides to treat a critically ill child brought into the emergency ward. Other colleagues accuse him of undermining the strike. Later, when complications arise, the patient’s family raises questions about liability, and professional associations debate whether Dr Yusuf acted lawfully by working during the strike.

Legal perspective

Under Nigerian law, the primary duty of a healthcare professional is to preserve life and provide care. While workers have a constitutional right to strike (Section 40 of the 1999 Constitution), this right is not absolute, particularly in sectors considered essential services – such as healthcare.

The National Health Act 2014 and various professional codes (Medical and Dental Practitioners Council of Nigeria, Pharmacy Council of Nigeria, Nursing and Midwifery Council of Nigeria) emphasise that healthcare workers must not deny emergency or life-saving care.

Thus, a professional who treats patients during a strike is not acting unlawfully. In fact, failure to treat in emergencies could expose professionals to liability for negligence, professional misconduct, or breach of statutory duty.

Determining liability

Courts or disciplinary bodies would examine:

Nature of the treatment – Was it emergency or elective care?

Standard of care – Did the professional exercise reasonable skill and diligence?

Outcome and causation – Was any harm caused by negligence or unavoidable circumstances?

Professional code compliance – Did the treatment align with ethical obligations despite the strike?

If the healthcare worker adhered to professional standards, liability is unlikely to arise simply because treatment occurred during industrial action.

 

Defences available to healthcare professionals

Duty to save life – Showing treatment was necessary to prevent serious harm or death.

Good faith action – Care was provided in the best interest of the patient, not to undermine collective action.

Emergency Doctrine – The law recognises that emergencies justify immediate intervention regardless of broader circumstances.

Professional ethics – Reference to medical or pharmaceutical codes that mandate care even in difficult contexts.

Practical advice for healthcare professionals

Prioritise emergencies and document thoroughly any treatment given during strikes.

Communicate clearly with patients and families about the scope of available services.

Stay within your professional competence – do not overstep due to reduced staffing.

Align with professional guidelines and keep malpractice insurance updated.

Engage with unions and associations to balance patient care with legitimate labour rights.

Closing insight

“The right to strike is important, but the duty to save lives is paramount. A healthcare professional who renders care in good faith during industrial action is more shielded by law than one who refuses lifesaving intervention.”

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here